Best Eye Pencil: 6 Eyeliner Pencils That Stay Put

The best eye pencil defines eyes with precision, whether you want a sharp wing or a smoky smudge. From long-wear gels to classic kohls, we’ve found six top-rated eyeliner pencils that glide on smooth and stay put.

Each pencil here is rated 4.2 stars or higher. Whether you need 36-hour wear or a budget waterproof winner, these eyeliners deliver bold, beautiful lines.

Comparison: Best Eye Pencils at a Glance

Product	Key Feature	Price	Best For
Maybelline TattooStudio Eyeliner Pencil	36-hour tattoo-lasting wear, 4.3 stars	Check current price	36-hour tattoo wear
L’Oreal Infallible Pro-Last Eyeliner	24-hour waterproof wear, 4.3 stars	Check current price	24-hour versatile
Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner Pencil	16-hour ColorStay wear, 4.4 stars	Check current price	16-hour ColorStay
Rimmel Soft Kohl Eyeliner Pencil	Classic kohl for smoky eyes, 4.3 stars	Check current price	Classic smoky kohl
NYX Epic Wear Eyeliner Stick	Epic long wear, 4.2 stars	Check current price	Bold epic wear
e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner	Retractable no-budge formula, 4.4 stars	Check current price	Budget no-budge

1. Maybelline TattooStudio Eyeliner Pencil

Maybelline’s TattooStudio pencil promises tattoo-like lasting power. Rated 4.3 stars, this gel pencil glides on smoothly and sets for up to 36 hours of smudge-proof, waterproof wear. It’s the drugstore liner that acts like a high-end gel.

Key features: 36-hour tattoo-lasting wear, 4.3 stars.

Pros:

• ✓ 4.3 stars, 36-hour wear
• ✓ Gel-like smooth application
• ✓ Waterproof and smudge-proof
• ✓ Great color payoff

Cons:

• ✗ Sets fast, blend quickly
• ✗ Can be hard to remove

Best for: Long-wear eyeliner that won’t budge.

Who should avoid: Those wanting easy removal.

2. L’Oreal Infallible Pro-Last Eyeliner

L’Oreal Infallible Pro-Last delivers 24 hours of waterproof eyeliner wear. Rated 4.3 stars, the built-in sharpener and smudger let you create both precise lines and smoky effects with one pencil.

Key features: 24-hour waterproof wear, 4.3 stars.

Pros:

• ✓ 4.3 stars, 24-hour wear
• ✓ Built-in sharpener and smudger
• ✓ Versatile: precise or smoky
• ✓ Waterproof

Cons:

• ✗ Needs sharpening
• ✗ Can drag if not warmed up

Best for: Versatile looks from day to night.

Who should avoid: Those wanting retractable convenience.

3. Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner Pencil

Revlon’s ColorStay eyeliner is known for staying put. Rated 4.4 stars, this pencil delivers rich color for up to 16 hours without fading or smudging. The smooth formula glides on without tugging delicate eye skin.

Key features: 16-hour ColorStay wear, 4.4 stars.

Pros:

• ✓ 4.4 stars, 16-hour wear
• ✓ Rich color payoff
• ✓ Smooth, no-tug application
• ✓ Trusted brand

Cons:

• ✗ Limited shade range
• ✗ Twist mechanism can break

Best for: Reliable all-day eyeliner.

Who should avoid: Those wanting dozens of shades.

4. L'Oreal Paris Infallible Pro-Last Pencil Eyeliner

The L’Oreal Paris Infallible Pro-Last pencil eyeliner is waterproof and smudge-resistant, and it glides on for everyday definition. It holds a 4.3 star average across more than 21,000 ratings. Brown is a softer alternative to black for daytime looks.

Key features: Classic kohl for smoky eyes, 4.3 stars.

Pros:

• ✓ Waterproof and smudge-resistant wear
• ✓ 4.3 stars from over 21,000 ratings
• ✓ Brown shade suits softer daytime looks

Cons:

• ✗ Pencil needs sharpening, no twist-up
• ✗ Brown may not suit those wanting intense black definition

Best for: Everyday waterproof brown eyeliner

Who should avoid: Skip if you want jet-black or a retractable pencil

5. NYX Epic Wear Eyeliner Stick

NYX Epic Wear lives up to its name with seriously long-wearing color. Rated 4.2 stars, this eyeliner stick delivers intense pigment that stays put through heat, humidity, and long days.

Key features: Epic long wear, 4.2 stars.

Pros:

• ✓ 4.2 stars, intense pigment
• ✓ Long-wearing formula
• ✓ Bold color options
• ✓ Good for creative looks

Cons:

• ✗ Can be drying
• ✗ Less creamy than others

Best for: Bold, creative eyeliner looks.

Who should avoid: Those with very dry eyelids.

6. e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner

e.l.f.’s No Budge eyeliner is the budget waterproof winner. Rated 4.4 stars, this retractable pencil glides on creamy then sets to a budge-proof finish. No sharpener needed, just twist and go.

Key features: Retractable no-budge formula, 4.4 stars.

Pros:

• ✓ 4.4 stars, budge-proof
• ✓ Retractable, no sharpener
• ✓ Creamy application
• ✓ Unbeatable price

Cons:

• ✗ Twist mechanism can stick
• ✗ Limited to basic shades

Best for: Budget waterproof eyeliner.

Who should avoid: Those wanting luxury packaging.

Frequently Asked Questions